Should Japan Build Nuclear-Powered Submarines? What a 52% “No” Poll Can and Cannot Tell Us [Japanese Reactions]

A Yomiuri poll found 52% of Japanese oppose owning nuclear-powered submarines. We explain what that means, the four yardsticks behind the debate, and Japanese reactions.

Key Points

ใƒปA Yomiuri Shimbun poll found 52% of respondents opposed Japan owning nuclear-powered submarines, ahead of 37% in favor.

ใƒปA nuclear-powered submarine runs on a reactor, which is a separate question from whether it carries nuclear weapons.

ใƒปThe poll does not show what people oppose, and the case for the submarines depends on mission, cost, crews and the alliance role.


52% Oppose Nuclear-Powered Submarines, 54% Back Higher Defense Spending

According to a nationwide poll by the Yomiuri Shimbun and Nippon Television’s NNN network conducted November 13 to 15, 2026, 52% of respondents opposed Japan having nuclear-powered submarines and 37% supported it. In the same poll, 54% supported increasing defense spending and 37% opposed it.

The poll was a telephone survey of voters nationwide with 1,033 respondents, and the response rate was 55% for landlines and 28% for mobile phones, according to NNN. The Yomiuri Shimbun reported that some in the ruling parties are calling for Japan to introduce nuclear-powered submarines.

The government plans to revise its three core security documents, including the National Security Strategy, by the end of the year, and the handling of nuclear-powered submarines has become one of the points at issue. In a plenary session of the House of Representatives on October 7, Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi said, “At present, nothing has been decided regarding the handling of a new means of propulsion for submarines.”

According to Kyodo News, members of the Liberal Democratic Party’s Research Commission on Security called on November 11 for a review of whether Japan should own nuclear-powered submarines. A government expert panel is arranging to compile its report in early December, Kyodo reported.


Related Articles


Nuclear Power Is Not the Same as Nuclear Weapons

A question of propulsion

A nuclear-powered submarine is a submarine propelled by the heat of an onboard reactor, which lets it travel fast and stay submerged for long periods without refueling. “Nuclear-powered” describes how the boat is driven, and it is a separate question from whether it carries nuclear weapons. The debate in Japan concerns submarines that would not carry nuclear weapons.

Nuclear-powered submarines also come in several types.

TypePropulsionMain weapons
Conventional submarine (operated by Japan)Batteries and dieselTorpedoes, anti-ship missiles
Nuclear-powered attack submarineReactorTorpedoes, cruise missiles
Nuclear-powered cruise missile submarineReactorLarge numbers of cruise missiles with conventional warheads
Nuclear-powered ballistic missile submarineReactorBallistic missiles with nuclear warheads

Six countries are generally counted as operating nuclear-powered submarines: the United States, Russia, China, the United Kingdom, France and India, all of which have nuclear weapons. Australia, South Korea and Brazil, which do not have nuclear weapons, are also seeking them.

In the Diet in July 2026, Defense Minister Shinjiro Koizumi listed their drawbacks: they are less quiet than conventional submarines, expensive, large, and require specialized expertise to maintain and operate.

Japan’s submarines run on batteries

All of the Japan Maritime Self-Defense Force’s submarines are conventional. The newest, the Taigei class, runs submerged on electricity stored in lithium-ion batteries.

In the Diet in April 2026, Koizumi compared the cost of a Taigei-class boat in the fiscal 2025 budget with the procurement cost of the U.S. Navy’s Virginia-class attack submarine, which he converted at 150 yen to the dollar.

SubmarineTypeCost per boat
Taigei class (Japan)Conventional, lithium-ion batteriesAbout 114 billion yen in the fiscal 2025 budget (about $760 million at 150 yen)
Virginia class (United States)Nuclear-powered attack submarineAbout $4.28 billion (about 642.2 billion yen at 150 yen)

Source: Defense Minister Koizumi’s answer in the House of Councillors Budget Committee on April 7, 2026.

Conventional submarines are small and can move very quietly at low speed. In exchange, they must regularly come near the surface to recharge their batteries, and they cannot sustain high speed underwater for long.

Why Japan has said it cannot have them

Article 2 of Japan’s Atomic Energy Basic Law, which governs the country’s nuclear programs, limits the use of nuclear energy to peaceful purposes.

In April 1965 the government issued a unified view of that clause. Besides ruling out nuclear weapons for the Self-Defense Forces, it said using nuclear energy to propel a ship is “likewise not permitted under the current circumstances, in which it has not become commonplace” in commercial vessels and elsewhere. The view followed a Diet answer the previous month by Junya Koizumi, then head of the Defense Agency and the grandfather of today’s defense minister.

In 2017 the government said in the Diet that using nuclear energy for propulsion is not prohibited by the Constitution but that it would keep the 1965 view, and a written government answer in December 2025 said there had been “no change.” The government also says the Three Non-Nuclear Principles, Japan’s policy of not possessing, not producing and not allowing the introduction of nuclear weapons, do not prohibit nuclear propulsion.

Fuel is another hurdle. As a party to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), Japan accepts safeguards by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), the inspections that keep nuclear material from being diverted to weapons. Fueling a nuclear-powered submarine would involve the procedure under Article 14 of Japan’s safeguards agreement with the IAEA, which allows nuclear material for non-weapons military uses to be removed from inspection under an arrangement.

Japan also has a difficult history with nuclear ships. The experimental ship Mutsu leaked radiation during a test voyage in September 1974 and then spent many years tied up at port.

The current push took shape from 2025

In October 2025 the Liberal Democratic Party and the Japan Innovation Party (Ishin) wrote into their coalition agreement a policy aimed at owning submarines that use “next-generation propulsion.” Koizumi has explained in the Diet that nuclear power is one of the options. In a June 2026 proposal, Ishin again urged Prime Minister Takaichi to introduce nuclear-powered submarines.

Countries around Japan are moving as well. As Koizumi also noted in the Diet, the United States approved South Korea’s construction of nuclear-powered submarines in 2025. Australia is acquiring them through AUKUS, its security partnership with the United States and the United Kingdom.

In July 2026, civic groups including Peace Boat and the Citizens’ Nuclear Information Center issued a joint statement saying Japan should not have nuclear-powered submarines. They argued that the submarines could go beyond Japan’s exclusively defense-oriented policy, would be costly and would conflict with the Atomic Energy Basic Law.


How Should the Need for Nuclear-Powered Submarines Be Measured?

What does the 52% opposition actually tell us?

The poll shows only that more respondents opposed owning nuclear-powered submarines than supported it. It does not show their reasons, or how they understood the term when they answered. The wording of the question could not be confirmed, so this article does not assess how it was asked.

In our search we found no national poll that asked people why they support or oppose the submarines, and no data on how many respondents confused nuclear-powered submarines with nuclear weapons. The 54% support for higher defense spending and the 52% opposition to the submarines also come from separate questions, so the totals do not show how the same people answered both.

Posts on X after the poll, a few of which appear in the Japanese Reactions section below, are not representative of public opinion, but they gave a range of reasons. Some wanted the money spent elsewhere, and some on the supporting side questioned how many opponents equate the submarines with nuclear weapons. Ishin’s proposal itself asks both for nuclear-powered submarines and for a review of the “not allowing the introduction” principle on nuclear weapons, so two issues that should be separate are being raised together at the entrance to the debate.

The value of a nuclear-powered submarine depends on its mission

How much it matters to stay submerged for long periods at high speed depends on what Japan wants its submarines to do. Lying in wait for enemy ships in nearby straits plays to the strengths of quiet conventional boats. Operating far out in the Pacific for long periods or trailing an opponent’s fleet makes the advantages of nuclear power much larger.

In the Diet in October 2026, Ishin lawmaker Keishi Abe argued for shifting from defending nearby waters toward denying an opponent freedom of movement in the open ocean. The Jiji Press news agency, however, reported, citing a government source, that there is “no consensus at all” within the government on what the submarines would be used for, with uniformed officers prioritizing patrol and surveillance and senior Defense Ministry officials prioritizing long-range missiles.

One former Maritime Self-Defense Force officer who comments publicly argues that what the U.S. Navy wants from allies is attack submarines that hunt Chinese submarines and other targets, while the ruling parties’ plan looks closer to a missile launch platform. Which mission Japan chooses changes both the performance it needs and how a nuclear boat should be compared with a conventional one.

How much would one boat cost, how many are needed, and who would crew them?

The U.S. attack submarine that Koizumi cited costs about 640 billion yen per boat, several times the Taigei class, although the two cannot be compared directly because the countries, budget years and sizes of the boats differ. Both figures are acquisition costs and do not include maintenance over a submarine’s service life.

The costs and effort also extend beyond the boat: handling fuel inspections, preparing for accidents, disposing of spent reactors and fuel, and a home port. The civic groups’ joint statement also named finding a community willing to host a home port and recruiting crews as challenges. Owning nuclear-powered submarines means owning the whole system on land that supports them.

Numbers matter too. Because some boats are always in port for maintenance or training, keeping even one at sea is generally said to require several. As far as we could confirm, no plan for how many boats Japan would own has been made public.

On personnel, the Self-Defense Forces as a whole recruited only 72% of their planned intake in fiscal 2025, according to the Defense Ministry’s 2026 white paper data. That figure is not specific to submarine crews, and the public documents we checked do not say how many people a nuclear-powered submarine would need or how many years training would take. Specialized crews who can run a reactor, and a system to train them, would be essential. With Japan’s population shrinking, there is also the question of how to recruit people for boats where they cannot freely contact the outside world for weeks.

Can uncrewed underwater drones replace nuclear-powered submarines?

Uncrewed underwater vehicles, essentially drones under the sea, are also being developed. Australia is fielding a large uncrewed underwater vehicle called Ghost Shark, but its government describes it as a complement to nuclear-powered submarines, not a replacement.

According to a U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) report, the U.S. Navy’s large uncrewed underwater vehicle Orca has spent about $885 million over eight years without a clear path to becoming a formal program. Radio waves travel poorly underwater, which generally limits how far such vehicles can be controlled remotely.

One view holds that nuclear-powered submarines will become more valuable as “motherships” for drones. Others worry about locking decades and huge sums into a field that is changing quickly.

Dividing roles with the United States, and how long it would take

One option, an extension of the current division of roles, is for Japan to stay without nuclear-powered submarines, concentrate on defending nearby waters and leave the distant ocean to U.S. nuclear submarines.

Yet one analysis finds that the United States has been building submarines at a pace of only a little more than one a year. A Congressional Research Service (CRS) report even lists, among options for Congress, a “division of labor” in which the U.S. Navy would keep and operate submarines that were due to be transferred to Australia.

Australia, for its part, is pursuing a long plan from its 2021 announcement: acquiring U.S. submarines in the 2030s and commissioning boats built in Australia in the early 2040s. The Australian government estimates the total cost of building, sustaining and providing facilities over several decades at up to 368 billion Australian dollars.

Even if Japan decides to own them, it is likely to take many years to settle the legal issues, the fuel procedures and the training of crews before deployment. Meanwhile, according to the U.S. Department of Defense’s 2024 report, China’s submarine force is projected to grow to 80 boats by 2035.

On China’s side, state media have reported that Japan’s review of its security policy threatens peace and stability in the region. The view that the submarines would be a deterrent precisely because their location is hard to read, and the concern that they would invite an arms race, both come from the same facts.

Not owning them also has a cost. If the technical and human foundations are not laid in advance, Japan could not acquire the submarines quickly even if it later decided it needed them.


Japanese Reactions to the Nuclear-Powered Submarine Poll

These are posts on X from the early hours and morning of November 16, 2026, Japan time, after the poll was published. They are not a measure of Japanese public opinion.

Cubbit, quoting another user’s reply that asked what the opponents were against when people already live on nuclear-generated electricity:

I’m somewhat against Japan owning nuclear submarines, but of course it’s not because of some nuclear allergy. It’s because I think a limited defense budget should go to improving conditions for SDF personnel and to preparing for modern warfare like drone combat.

If anything, I don’t understand the reason to waste money on a super-expensive weapon that can stay submerged for months when we’re not even going on expeditions. (translated)


Neko Seal:

In the Yomiuri Shimbun’s November poll, 54% supported increasing defense spending.

On the other hand, only 37% supported Japan having nuclear submarines.

Strengthening defense and having nuclear submarines are not the same thing. Many people seem to be thinking about them separately.

The government plans to revise the three security documents by the end of the year, and whether to have nuclear submarines has become an issue in talks between the ruling parties. The ruling Japan Innovation Party stated explicitly in its proposal that nuclear submarines “should be introduced urgently.”

Either way, what will be bought with the extra money? I want them to explain that to us, all of it.

Prices are already high, and the burden keeps growing to fund defense spending. (translated)


Goda, quoting a Yahoo! News post about the poll:

A poll on owning nuclear submarines, which I have long been waiting for. Very grateful…

Well, that aside, we also have to talk about how many hidden respondents in this think nuclear submarine = nuclear weapon.

[Quoting the report] “Opposed” at 52% outnumbered “in favor” at 37% on Japan having nuclear submarines. (translated)


Duke:

52% “opposed” to Japan owning nuclear submarines, 37% in favor… More in favor than I expected. But it is dangerous that more than a majority of the public still doesn’t understand how severe Japan’s security environment is. Why would anyone need to oppose something that makes their own country safer?

In the end, it comes down to relying on the missiles on nuclear submarines… it would not be strange at all if that time came. They absolutely should be introduced.

By the way, the one pushing for introduction is probably Fumitake Fujita, co-leader of the Japan Innovation Party. The LDP is said to be reluctant. I feel like there have been more and more moments lately where it comes down to relying on Mr. Fujita. (translated)


Four Yardsticks Beyond Performance

Neither “because it’s nuclear” nor “because it’s capable”

What the 52% are opposing cannot be identified from these figures. A nuclear-powered submarine is not a nuclear weapon, but being highly capable does not by itself decide whether Japan needs one.

In which waters Japan wants its submarines to operate and for what mission, where the money would come from, who would crew them and who would train those crews, and how to divide roles with the United States. Supporters and skeptics alike reach different conclusions depending on which of these four yardsticks they weigh most heavily.

How far the expert panel report expected in December and the three security documents due by the end of the year address these four questions remains to be seen. Whether the debate can move past the impression left by the word “nuclear” and settle what yardsticks to judge by is likely to shape what the discussion actually becomes.


Frequently Asked Questions

Does “nuclear-powered submarine” mean a submarine with nuclear weapons?

No. A nuclear-powered submarine is driven by an onboard reactor, and whether it carries nuclear weapons is a separate matter. The submarines under discussion in Japan would not carry nuclear weapons, and the Japanese government says its Three Non-Nuclear Principles do not prohibit nuclear propulsion.

Is Japan legally allowed to have nuclear-powered submarines?

Under current government policy, no. A unified government view from April 1965 says nuclear propulsion for the Self-Defense Forces is not permitted under the Atomic Energy Basic Law while it has not become commonplace, and a written government answer in December 2025 said that view has not changed, even though the government told the Diet in 2017 that the Constitution does not prohibit it.

How much would a nuclear-powered submarine cost compared with Japan’s current submarines?

Defense Minister Shinjiro Koizumi told the Diet in April 2026 that a Taigei-class submarine cost about 114 billion yen in the fiscal 2025 budget, while a U.S. Virginia-class attack submarine costs about $4.28 billion, or about 642.2 billion yen at 150 yen to the dollar. The countries, budget years and sizes differ, and neither figure includes maintenance.

How did Japanese social media react to the nuclear submarine poll?

In the posts on X we reviewed from November 16, 2026, one opponent said the issue was not a “nuclear allergy” but spending priorities such as SDF personnel and drone warfare, and another user asked the government to explain what the extra defense money would buy. Two supporters questioned how many respondents equate nuclear submarines with nuclear weapons or argued that the public underestimates Japan’s security environment. These posts are a small sample, not a measure of Japanese public opinion.

Sekahan on YouTube

We publish video summaries of articles like this one, along with short clips built around Japanese reactions.


Reference Links

ใ“ใฎใ‚จใƒณใƒˆใƒชใƒผใ‚’ใฏใฆใชใƒ–ใƒƒใ‚ฏใƒžใƒผใ‚ฏใซ่ฟฝๅŠ 
Sekahan
Sekahan

Editor of Sekahan, a Japanese news-analysis blog. Writes English explainers built on Japanese-language primary sources such as Teikoku Databank reports, government white papers, and official statistics.

Articles: 728

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CAPTCHA